Peer Review Process
Indonesian Journal of Blood and Transfusion
Peer Review Process
IDJBT employs a rigorous double-blind peer review process for all submitted manuscripts. In this process, the identities of both authors and reviewers are concealed from each other, ensuring objective and unbiased evaluation of the scientific merit of each submission. All decisions are made by the editorial board based on reviewer recommendations.
Double-Blind Review Minimum 2 Reviewers Target: 4–8 Weeks
Review Workflow
1
Submission
Authors submit manuscripts via the OJS online submission system. Submissions must comply with the author guidelines. An acknowledgement of receipt is sent automatically.
2
Editorial Desk Review
The Editor-in-Chief or a handling editor performs an initial check for compliance with journal scope, formatting requirements, and basic scientific soundness. Manuscripts that do not meet minimum standards may be rejected at this stage without external review.
3
Plagiarism Screening
Manuscripts that pass the desk review are screened for similarity using plagiarism detection software. Manuscripts with unacceptable similarity levels are returned to authors or rejected.
4
Reviewer Assignment
The editor assigns at least two independent expert reviewers with relevant expertise. Reviewers are selected to avoid conflicts of interest with authors. Authors may suggest preferred or excluded reviewers in their cover letter.
5
Peer Review
Reviewers evaluate the manuscript for scientific rigor, originality, clarity, ethical compliance, and relevance to the journal's scope. Reviewers are asked to complete their review within 3–4 weeks.
6
Editorial Decision
Based on reviewer recommendations, the editor issues one of four decisions: Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject. The decision letter and anonymous reviewer comments are sent to the corresponding author.
7
Revision & Re-review
Authors must submit a revised manuscript along with a point-by-point response to all reviewer comments. Revised manuscripts may be re-evaluated by the original reviewers. Minor revisions are typically checked by the editor only.
8
Final Decision & Publication
Upon acceptance, the manuscript is sent for copyediting, typesetting, and proofreading. The corresponding author reviews the final proof before publication. Accepted articles are published in the next available issue.
Editorial Decision Types
Accept
Manuscript accepted as submitted or with minor editorial corrections only
Minor Revision
Small changes required; typically checked by editor only, not returned to reviewers
Major Revision
Substantial changes required; revised manuscript returned to original reviewers
Reject
Manuscript does not meet the journal's standards; not suitable for publication
Appeals
Authors who believe a rejection decision is erroneous may submit a formal appeal to the Editor-in-Chief within 30 days of the decision. Appeals must include a detailed rebuttal addressing each reviewer comment and a clear justification for reconsideration. The Editor-in-Chief's decision on appeals is final.